Four Witnesses: The Early Church in Her Own Words
Have you ever read a book so convicting that you kind of wish you hadn’t read it? That’s this book.
Four Witnesses is a not-so-brief history of the early church from the perspective of four of its founders: Clement of Rome, Ignatius of Antioch, Justin Martyr and Irenaeus of Lyons. It tells their stories in a personable way that helps to give an idea of what the early church was like, as well as giving a testimony to their dedication amidst persecution.
The most important part, though, comes in Bennett’s afterword, where he gives his own spiritual journey that took place while he was researching and writing the book. The underlying idea he points out, that he was convicted about himself, is this: when looking at the early church’s structure, hierarchy, practices and beliefs, the best model of that exists today in the form of the Catholic church. Furthermore, he argues that, when looking at certain actions that the early church swiftly did away with as heresy, they come scarily close to the way the Church is carried out by evangelicals and even Anglicans.
This has just scratched the surface. I don’t want to let one book be a strong enough force for me to drastically alter my faith, but it’s hard to not feel swayed strongly by the power of his words and the logic and support behind his arguments.
More to come, I’m sure.
- April 30th, 2009 at 8:00 am
- Tags: Four Witnesses, Rod Bennett
- Category: books, Faith, Goals, Personal

If the Catholics ditched the notion of extrabiblical revelation (ie. the Papacy, the elevation of tradition), then I don’t think evangelicals would have much of an issue with their customs and oddities.
The reality is, by elevating man and tradition to Jesus’ position as head of the church, they not only go against Scripture, but against God.
Note: The above includes broad generalizations. Don’t take it to be a painting of all Catholicism… just most of it.
Comment by Code — April 30, 2009 @ 8:53 amFurther Thoughts:
Comment by Code — April 30, 2009 @ 9:20 amWhat’s with the present-day preoccupation with thinking that the Early Church is a template for church in general? Shouldn’t the New Testament Church take precedence anyways, since that’s what we have recorded in authoritative Scripture – not to mention that it’s the church that had the Apostles amidst it, as opposed to just ‘early church fathers’ like Origen and Clement. I’m glad to take the NT as my “model” of Ecclesiology any day.
I want to read it.
Comment by Sarah — April 30, 2009 @ 9:59 am[...] post is in response to comments I got about my entry about the book Four Witnesses. The following responses aren’t things I’m saying with full authority and 100% belief, [...]
Pingback by Questioning Catholicism | Josh Mock — May 5, 2009 @ 8:17 am