Don’t pretend like you have the answer

In the continuing saga of “to be wise is to be sad,” financial blogger Ramit Sethi chimes in:

Have you ever noticed how everyone seems to have “the answer” to the healthcare crisis or the economic meltdown? The problem is, they usually don’t see above their own situations to the larger problems. That’s why any one of our opinions is largely irrelevant.

Everyone’s got an opinion, usually drawn from their own narrow experiences, not seeing the full picture.

This is why product managers know how difficult it is to ask their users what features they want in a product.

It’s why politicians can’t just tactically respond to what people want, but have to show leadership in what they need.

And so, someone else adds to my argument that it’s okay to not care about things you aren’t an expert at. I don’t have too strong an opinion about these financial bailouts and stimulus packages because it is such a complex situation that I can’t imagine any one person could possibly have a good response that will fix the majority of the problem (which is really the best we can hope for). Considering that not even career economists can’t agree on this, my guess is it’s beyond pretty much all of us.

I write about things like this sometimes in hopes that I might encourage others to also not care about things that are beyond their comprehension and, really, to admit that there are things beyond their comprehension. Try it sometime. It’s kind of nice.

Comments (2)

  1. I think part of what I love about the Planet Money podcast from NPR is how often they stress the fact that there is no overwhelming consensus from economists about what to do. The schools of thought are so wide ranging, and there are no proven solutions because there are no labs to test economic theories. No methods for reducing variables.

    There seems to be only one thing they do agree on: something has to be done, but I think they could spend another 100 years arguing over what to do.

    And it’s all way over my head, though I’m trying to learn to see the clouds and the sun.

    Comment by Jenni Smith — February 19, 2009 @ 12:11 am
  2. [...] David Dark from an article in the latest issue of Relevant Magazine. And, once again, file it with that topic that I’ve talked about many times. If we think we have faith, because we faithfully protect [...]

    Pingback by I’m an agnostic | Josh Mock — July 16, 2009 @ 11:59 am

Leave a comment

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

All content on JoshMock.com is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License.
Creative Commons License